People mostly get confused about WiFi extender or WiFi repeater .
It’s obvious, as nothing has been clarified by the manufacturers, what is a clear difference between these two.
However, there is the third entry here in the WIFI booster adapter category – The Powerline Adapters.
Technically, it’s way offbeat from the techniques used by repeaters and extenders. Nonetheless, which one is better in a war of powerline adapter vs. WiFi extender?
Which one will pull better if you just have turned your garage into a study room or office?
We’ll be finding this answer today while shedding some light on the working of both devices.
PowerLine Adapter Vs. WiFi Extender: Do Powerline Ethernet Adapters work?
So, between the Powerline adapter vs. WiFi extender, it’s pretty absolute that the powerline method beat the race marginally.
With lots of tricks regarding placement, setup, and range in the WiFi extender category, the powerline WiFi booster is pretty simple and much practical for multi-story apartments and cornering living rooms.
But how these both techniques contrast from each other, it’s no illusion, but a reality.
The PowerLine Method – Are PowerLine Adapters Good?
The basic notion of using a powerline is to get rid of multiple WiFi hotspots to bring Internet coverage to your desired area.
For this purpose, Powerline adapters utilize your main electricity home wiring to transmit network data through it.
It looks so, but it isn’t the case here, and it’s a way easier setup than WiFi extenders.
As WiFi boosters totally rely on the placement of the access points, signal strengths, and other issues, Powerline WiFi Booster is free from those headaches and hassles.
You get pairs of powerline adapters – One gets connected to your router and main electricity socket, the other find a place near you and gets attached to the socket near you.
In that case, speed degradation or packet dropping solely relies on the quality of your wiring.
The more goodness, the sweetest the net speed will be.
But, does it achieve the same amount of speed as Ethernet does?
The Powerline WiFi booster network curbs most of the data packet loss that you face in the WiFi extenders hotspot network, but some negligible lags you still undergo.
Other than this, the Powerline adapter capabilities also weigh the most. It entirely depends on the model and make of the Powerline WiFi booster adapters, but the maximum range should be under 200M for a better experience.
Pros and Cons of Powerline Adapters:
Yes, it’s a much more reliable way than WiFi Boosters as it diminishes the demand for WiFi hotspots at your place. Nonetheless, this way also comes with some of its green and red flags.
- Simple setup; doesn’t require much technical knowledge
- Much reliable than Wireless systems
- Minimal loss of network speed than WiFi Boosters.
- Not so expensive
- Fully portable, it can move anywhere within the operating range
- Lagging is still an issue here.
- It only works on one circuit channel. Houses with multiple stories having separate circuits will not comply with its working architecture.
- Not a replacement of Ethernet network
- It Relies on the quality of your wiring, as it faces interference when any heavy electrical load draws power like extension leads.
WiFi Extenders: Are these Good Enough?
To all non-techies about WiFi range-extending procedure, they somehow find the easiest solution on the internet in the shape of WiFi Extenders.
This technique consists of single or multiple WiFi access points that rebroadcast the WiFi signals to a more extended range.
This seems easy, factually, but lots of technical complexities become barriers of your way while setting it up.
First of all, placement is a kind of head-scratching issue that you’ll come across. Placing the WiFi booster access point is crucial as setting it up at a place where the signals already don’t hold up firmly, the performance will remain a question mark.
Place your WiFi Extender adapter in between the connecting device and router where the quality and strength of signals remain on high notes.
Nonetheless, setting up properly still brings a lag in the speed. It depends on the model and make of the WiFi extender as standardly; these devices attain a single band for transmitting data.
To break out this problem, always prefer a dual-band device that’ll employ separate channels for sending and receiving data packets.
Pros and Cons of WiFi Extenders:
Though they are a better breed of WiFi Boosters, but when comparing powerline networking vs. WiFi extenders, these carry their own pros and cons:
- A budget-friendly way of boosting WiFi signals
- No need to replace your original router
- Can connect to multiple users
- No unnecessary struggles to set it up
- A feasible solution to cover larger areas and multi-stories
- Lagging in speed
- Network interference of other wireless devices like microwave
- Sometimes becomes difficult to set overlapping channels
The Bottom Line – Wrapping Up the Story
So, in a war of powerline adapters vs. WiFi extenders, who is the winner?
Though, with both setups, you can’t get the Ethernet-like performance, yet Powerline Adapters are an excellent story to narrate to users who are struggling with lousy signal coverage.
Powerline Ethernet Adapters also stock some drawbacks, but it’s the surest way to fix a low coverage mess among all available range boosting techniques.