The 5 Best Undercounter Ice Makers Reviewed
An undercounter ice maker enables you to make a generous amount of ice, without taking up much-needed space in your kitchen.
Sometimes known as a built-in ice maker, these appliances can sit snugly under worktops or islands in the same way that your dishwasher or cooker does.
In addition, they can be used in commercial environments, such as bars and restaurants, to ensure you can always serve drinks at optimum temperatures.
Choosing a home ice machine is an important decision, particularly if you’re looking for a long-term solution to your ice-making needs. As well as producing an appropriate amount of ice, you’ll want an under counter ice maker which is easy to clean and simple to use.
Unlike portable ice makers, under counter units take a little more thought.
In addition to this, you may be looking for more features, such as fast-freeze programs and ice cube size selections. Of course, noise and energy consumption are also worth considering when it comes to finding the best home ice machine.
While some ice makers are fairly noisy, you can find a range of undercounter ice makers which have been designed to operate quickly and efficiently. Our undercounter ice maker reviews make it easy to find all the information you need when you’re looking for a built-in ice maker.
If you’re unsure which model is right for you, take a look at our round-up below. We go through each model in detail, and highlight their strengths and weakness. Here are the ice makers we looked at:
Best Under Counter Ice Makers
After looking at the models available, pricing, features, and feedback from owners, we present our picks for the best undercounter ice makers:
Designed as a commercial unit, the Scotsman CU50GA is routinely used in business premises. However, its compact size means it could be a good choice for residential environments too. If you’re looking for a home ice machine, don’t be put off by the fact that this model is designed with businesses in mind.
Indeed, if an ice maker is capable of dealing with commercial demand and usage, it should be more than equipped to deliver efficient ice-making at home! As the CU50GA measures just 22 x 14.9 x 34.4 inches, it won’t take up too much space. Advantageous for both business and home use, you won’t have to give up much valuable space to fit this unit in. However, it does weigh around 100 pounds, so you’re going to need some help moving it into position.
It features a built-in drain pump, so it’s easy to remove water, and the control panel will ensure you can keep up-to-date with current water conditions. This handy feature means you won’t waste time replenishing the machine with fresh water when you don’t need to. Simply check the condition before use and you can get the most out of the Scotsman CU50GA.
A 15 Amp circuit is required, so you’ll need to ensure that this model will complement your existing power setup. Aside from this, however, it has a great range of features and is designed to be easy to use. As well as being perfect as an undercounter ice maker, the Scotsman CU50GA is approved for outdoor use as too. If you have an outside bar, BBQ area or even a cabin, this model could be perfect for your needs.
While buyers have been mostly pleased with the performance of this built-in ice maker, there has been some differing opinions regarding the volume of the machine. While some purchasers maintain it’s unobtrusive and quiet, others have found it to operate at quite a high noise level. Of course, personal opinion can have an impact when it comes to noise levels, but this might be something you want to take into account if you’re looking for a super-quiet home ice maker.
- PRODUCTION: Produces up to 64 lb. of gourmet ice in 24 hours and stores up to 26 lb. of ice.
- COMPACT: 15” cabinet width for placement in tight locations.
- QUALITY: Uniquely-shaped, crystal-clear, slow-melting, taste-free, odorless ice - won’t dilute the flavor of drinks.
- TECHNOLOGY: Water-quality sensor detects hard water conditions and control system purges mineral laden water with every harvest cycle, which helps extend the time between cleanings.
- EASY-TO-USE: User-friendly control panel informs whether power is on, alerts a no-water condition, and a time to clean reminder.
Weighing just 66 pounds and measuring 17 x 13.9 x 25.1 inches, this U-Line model is ideal if you’re looking for a compact undercounter ice maker. Made from steel, with a black finish, it will look stylish and chic in any environment.
When it comes to functionality, the vast majority of undercounter ice maker reviews pitch the U-Line highly. Indeed, most purchasers are more than happy with the quality of ice it produces, as well as the time it takes to prepare a batch of ice. Furthermore, there are minimal reports of excess noise, which makes it popular with buyers who are actively looking for a quiet home ice machine.
However, some buyers have found installation to be a little tricky. Some have chosen to purchase an additional installation kit, which seems to enhance the ease of installing your new ice machine. Of course, your existing setup and connection may play a role in the installation too. Despite this, even users who found it tricky to install were pleased with their purchase.
Although the U-Line UBI95B00A Undercounter Crescent Ice Maker does receive a large number of positive reviews, some users may be disappointed with its capabilities in terms of how much ice it can produce. Advertised as making up to 23 pounds of ice per day, this is less than some portable, countertop models.
If 23 pounds of ice is likely to fulfill your daily needs, the U-Line Crescent Ice Maker could be the perfect choice. However, if you think you’ll regularly require a larger amount of ice, you might want to opt for a slightly larger built-in ice maker.
- Only requires a 1/4 inch outside diameter water line connection
- Daily ice rate of up to 23 lbs
- Uses less than three gallons of water for approximately 23 lbs. Of ice and minimal electricity
- It is a durable and reliable undercounter ice machine.
With no drain line required, many people will find the EdgeStar IB120SS an attractive option. Easy to install and straightforward to use, you can start making as pretty much straight away with this model.
Furthermore, this EdgeStar Ice Maker has a lot of versatility, so you can modify it to suit your needs. For example, it can be used as a freestanding or built-in ice maker. If you want to integrate it into your kitchen, office or bar, you’ll find it easy to do so, but, if you simply want to plug it in and use it as a freestanding machine, you’ll have the freedom to do so.
In addition to this, it features a reversible door, so you can opt for left or right swinging. This is a handy feature that ensures you can use the EdgeStar without encroaching on nearby appliances, cabinets or cupboards.
As the unit is ADA compliant, it’s also ideal for use in commercial settings or business premises. If you plan on installing an ice maker in a café or in a workplace, for example, you may be looking for a model that is ADA compliant. If so, the EdgeStar IB120SS Built-in Ice Maker may be the perfect choice.
The ice maker itself comes with a 25-foot, ¼” water line, so you’ll have everything you need to connect it. In addition, an ice bucket and scoop are included, so it’s easy to transport the ice cubes once they’re ready to be used.
However, some users have been disappointed with the amount of ice the EdgeStar IB120SS can produce. At just 12 pounds per day, it is significantly less than some others on the market. Of course, whether this is suitable for your needs will come down to personal preference. If you’re looking for an ice maker to make a relatively small amount of ice on a daily basis, it may be ideal. However, if you have a large family, regular visitors or will be using the unit in a commercial setting, you may prefer an ice machine that can produce a larger amount of ice in a 24-hour period.
If you’re happy with less than 12 pounds of ice per day, the EdgeStar does offer a lot of benefits. With no need to install a drain line and increased versatility, it does tick many boxes. Indeed, many people who have purchased the unit leave positive undercounter ice maker reviews, so the EdgeStar ice machine is definitely one worth considering.
- Front venting for built-in or freestanding installation; ADA Height Compliant
- 25 foot long 1/4" water line connection included; Reversible door for left or right hand swing; Ice scoop included
- Easy, convenient, and inexpensive installation; On/off power switch; Auto shut-off when ice bin is full
- Produces up to 12 pounds of ice per day; Stores up to 6 pounds of ice; Dimensions 25 1/4" H x 15" W x 18 1/2" D
- This unit also operates as a freezer and will keep your ice frozen; No drain line required
If you’re looking for a built-in ice maker capable of producing a large amount of ice, the Whynter UIM-502SS might fit the bill. The unit can make up to 50 pounds of ‘restaurant-quality’ ice every 24 hours and store up to 25 pounds of ice, so you’ll never run out of ice cubes again!
It’s front-vented, so you can choose to use it as a built-in ice maker or as a freestanding machine. With a 50 cubic feet capacity, it’s not going to be the smallest undercounter ice machine, but its capabilities may make up for this. Measuring 24.5 x 15 x 32.5 inches and weighing 77 pounds, it will take up more space than some other models. However, when you compare its capabilities, it certainly doesn’t seem oversized.
As well as an ice scoop, you’ll receive a water hose and drain hose when you purchase the Whynter UIM-502SS, which comes in handy for installation. While it does only offer one size of ice cube, this doesn’t appear to be a drawback for the vast majority of purchasers. The controls on the back of the machine do enable you to modify the thickness of the ice, although some users have found these buttons a little hard to access. Indeed, if you’re planning on using this as a built-in unit, you may want to find the perfect settings for you before you put it in place.
Many buyers have also been impressed with how quiet the unit is, which is impressive when you consider just how much ice it can produce per day. This ensures it’s a great choice for a commercial or home environment, particularly if you don’t want to be disturbed by excess or unnecessary noise.
One-button operation ensures the Whynter UIM-502SS is easy to use and straightforward to operate, while the CFC-free compressor is popular with environmentally conscious buyers. As an Energy Star rated unit, it runs efficiently and doesn’t use excess power, so you can rest assured you won’t spend over the odds when it comes to powering the machine.
- Makes 50 lbs. of restaurant quality clear ice cubes in 24 hours | Removable storage bin | Door swing reversible
- Product dimensions – 24.5” L x 15” W x 33” H (Add 2” depth with handle installed) | Recommended clearance space – 1” On top, 4” On the back | Approximate ice cube dimension – ¾” x ¾” x 1” | Estimate life span – 5-7 years | Indoor only
- This item is insulated but does not keep the harvested ice frozen | Built-in or freestanding installation (front venting)
- Makes 50 lbs. of restaurant quality clear ice cubes in 24 hours | Stores up to 25 lbs. of ice with auto shut-off when ice bin is full
- Sleek stainless steel door and black cabinet | This item is designed to be plumbed into a water line or to be used with a water filtration system
Complete with ice scoop, drain hose, and water line, you can install the Koldfront KIM450BL as soon as it arrives. However, Koldfront does recommend you purchase an additional water filter to enhance ice production. A simple 3-step installation process ensures you can be up and running quickly, so there’s no need to wait too long for your first batch of ice to be prepared.
Depending on where you plan to use your built in ice maker, you may also need to purchase a condensate pump. While you won’t usually need a pump if you’re running wastewater to a nearby drain, if there is any significant distance between the unit and the drain, a pump may be needed.
Like many built-in ice makers, the Koldfront KIM450BL produces ice in sheets, which is then broken up into cubes. When falling into the ice holder, this usually happens automatically, but some users find they need to use the ice scoop to further break down the sheets of ice. Many report that purchasing an additional, larger, aluminum scoop makes these easier, although you may find that the accompanying ice scoop does the job.
This Koldfront model features insulated ice storage, so you can keep your ice cold for longer than in other models. With 25 pounds of storage, it’s handy to know that you’ll have fresh ice available whenever you need it. In addition to this, the Koldfront KIM450BL Built-in 15-inch wide clear ice maker is capable of producing 50 pounds of ice per day.
If you’re looking for an ice maker to use in a commercial setting or to install at home, this could be the best unit for you. With a high capacity, you’ll have all the ice you need, and its compact size means it won’t take up too much space. Measuring 23.4 x 14.6 x 32.6 inches and weighing 76.7 pounds, it’s relatively small for an ice maker of such capabilities and functionality.
While some users have found the Koldfront KIM450BL to be fairly noisy, this doesn’t seem to be a view that’s shared by every purchaser. If you’re looking for a super-quiet home ice machine, this may not be the model for you. However, if you’re happy with a reasonable amount of operational noise and you’re looking for a unit capable of producing a large volume of ice, the Koldfront clear ice maker might be just what you’re looking for.
- Up to 45 lbs. of ice production/day; 25 lbs. of ice storage; Insulated ice storage
- Removable ice bin; Ice scoop included; Gravity drain only (Drain required); Reversible door
- For built-in or freestanding applications; NOTE: Installation by a licensed plumber is strongly recommended
- Simple 3-step installation; Produces restaurant quality clear, hard, cubed ice
- Ice comes out in sheets and will have to be broken apart; Dimensions: 32.8" H x 14.6" W x 23.6" D
Making The Decision
Since an under counter ice maker is a larger appliance that has both counter space, wiring, and plumbing considerations, it makes sense to plan wisely. Here is a good YouTube video that walks you through some of the additional items to think about:
- Best Solar Powered Motion Security Lights
- Best Solar Powered Pool Heaters
- Best Space Heater For Large Room